IDBOOK Review

Name: IDBOOK Review
Item: IDBOOK
Rating: 9.20
Author: greenrocks

Detailed review by greenrocks

9.2

Overall Rating

out of 10

greenrocks

Reviewed on August 18, 2025

Vermont

General Review

Did a group order of Vermont IDs during an IDBOOK 50% promo in June.

Communication

10.0/10

IDBOOK responded to the few questions I had relatively quickly.

Cost/Value

10.0/10

Nothing beats $25 an ID for 4 or more.

Shipping

8.0/10

Took just over a little more than a month from payment to delivery. Didn't expect it'd take that long but it was a promo.

Template Quality

10.0/10

Looks great. Has all the fine details and is the highlight of this order.

Photoshop Quality

8.0/10

The photoshop job on all the IDs was sub par. Framing was inconsistent/incorrect in all the IDs, and only one had added shadows. Too much shoulder in all but 2 of the IDs. My personal photo looks extremely shopped even after taken on a high quality camera/w white background. Background is too dark a shade of blue.

Holo/OVI

10.0/10

Holos look fine and are identical to a real VT.

UV Features

10.0/10

Vermont's holo doubles as the UV

Scanning

8.0/10

Comes up as potentially fake on BCS and actual bar scanner.

Signature

8.0/10

Most of the order came out fine. One ID's sig was almost non existent. IDBOOK's site said they'd supplement a custom signature if quality was an issue on a submitted one.

Conclusion

10.0/10

Being from Vermont, I really, really wanted to like this ID. Everything is great except for the photoshop and scanning. For $25 I shouldn't be complaining, but these are almost unusable anywhere because of these issues. Brought them to a bar my friends work at in South Carolina and was told they were the worst they'd seen in a while. Extremely disappointed.