9.5
Overall Rating
out of 10
G
Guwop_1
Reviewed on August 18, 2025
NewGeneral Review
I won this ID in a giveaway from: r/MagicFakes, here is my review:
Detailed Ratings
Communication
10.0/10
Sent us (giveaway winners) a DM on what to do and it was pretty simple and straightforward. After a week he said all the IDs were made and were going to be shipped and delivered within the week and it was. All in all great customer service with Magic.
Cost/Value
10.0/10
Even though I didn't have to pay for mine, it's still a pretty great value for people interested in purchasing the realest fake you can get your hands on for about $100. And you also get two IDs incase you lose one. If I didn't win the giveaway I would have definitely bought one.
Shipping
10.0/10
Excellent shipping time, I got mine within 2 weeks of ordering mine. (It was rush shipping)
Template Quality
9.0/10
Everything looks as close it possibly can get. I haven't really noticed anything that looks different from originals. I would give this a 10 but things aren't always perfect and can never be exact but this is as close as you can get with any fake on the market and no will ever notice if it's slightly off because I don't even notice anything off.
Photoshop Quality
10.0/10
I was paying really close attention to the picture but in my opinion it looks great and professional. Nothing looks out of the ordinary and looks just like a picture you would take in the DMV.
Holo/OVI
9.0/10
I haven't really tested this out for myself buy my friend who actually referred me to Magic has. All he did was put a UV light over the ID and checked it for holograms which was there and it was very hard to tell the difference from the original hologram and the fake. To state again, I didn't test this but according to my friend's observation, it's as close and you can get with any fake ID.
UV Features
9.0/10
I haven't really tested this out for myself buy my friend who actually referred me to Magic has. All he did was put a UV light over the ID and checked it for holograms which was there and it was very hard to tell the difference from the original hologram and the fake. To state again, I didn't test this but according to my friend's observation, it's as close and you can get with any fake ID.
Scanning
9.0/10
This ID has no problem scanning at any place. I've used in dispensaries, bars, liquor stores and convenience stores and they have all scanned without any problem.
Signature
9.0/10
The signature looks great to anyone not really trying to inspect it and compare to originals, It's really not noticeable but its a little subtle difference, the bold feels a little more raised but unsure if that's because the ID I was comparing with is worn from years of use. But it's barely noticeable and I doubt any bouncer or security guard will question how the bold feels.
Conclusion
10.0/10
Best fake I have ever held in my hand. It really doesn't get that better from here, Magic has done a great job producing these. If you are going to use this ID in any bar, store or dispensary it is guaranteed to work. If you looking for the best fake and looking to spend $100, I fully endorse MagicFakeID. For the price it's genuinely a steel. You get two IDs incase you lose one and most important factor is that it really works, meaning it passes the scan, holograms and uv.
Review Photos (1)
Vendor Information
EvolvedIDs
Category
trusted
State
New
Average Rating
8.8/10
Total Reviews
562
Uncertainty Factor: Medium
Review Stats
Review Date
Aug 18, 2025
Overall Score
9.5/10
Photos Included
1